Donate search
Listen Now The Erick Erickson Show streaming live arrow_right_alt close


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • send Email
  • print Print

Pro-Life Texas State Rep. Jeff Leach Delivers Death Sentence to 110,000 Preborn Human Beings

by James Silberman Read Profile arrow_right_alt

The culture of death was assailed on Monday as 446 abolitionists showed up to the Texas State capitol to support the Abolition of Abortion in Texas Act (TX HB896), a bill which would completely abolish abortion in the state. 330 of them testified in favor of the bill, causing the hearing to last until nearly 3 a.m.

Wednesday brought somber news, however, as Texas House Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence Committee Chair Jeff Leach (R-Plano) released a statement declaring that the TX HB896 will not be voted on. Leach lambasted the bill because it criminalizes abortion by “subject[ing] women who undergo abortions to criminal liability.”

For three reasons, Leach is horrifically mistaken. First, abortion isn’t actually illegal if parents who murder their sons and daughters have automatic immunity. If only the abortionist faces justice, do-it-yourself abortion is legal. And with the abortion industry moving toward DIY abortion anyway, a bill providing legal penalty only for the abortionist accomplishes nothing but expedite the evolution of the abortion industry.

Second, the law is a deterrent. Among those testifying in favor of the Abolition of Abortion in Texas Act was Jason Storms, a pastor and an activist with Operation Save America. He told his emotional story of creating a child with his high school girlfriend and choosing abortion with her in the mid-1990s.

“I was guilty as an accomplice in the murder of my own child, and I should have been prosecuted accordingly,” Storms told the committee. “Mothers and fathers – parents – right now in Texas can be charged with parental neglect, parental abuse, and even parental homicide when we see the tragedy of parents taking the lives of their own children. It’s because mothers and fathers have a duty to love and protect their children. That responsibility doesn’t start when they’re born, but it starts when they’re conceived.”

“Here’s a fact: my girlfriend and I, if we knew we would’ve been facing homicide charges, would never have aborted that child. That child would be alive today. I’d have a 22-year-old little child that I could celebrate life with right now that’s not here. The law is a deterrent to crime. We shouldn’t think of this only as a matter of putting a woman on the stand. We should think of this as a great deterrent. Men and women would not think of doing this if we stood firm on the law and provided equal protection for these children.”

Most mothers and fathers who are murdering their children wouldn’t be doing so if they knew they’d have to face justice. That justice needs to be there. It’s unjust and immoral for it not be.

Third, abortion bans which exempted parents from legal penalty are what led to the legalization of abortion in the first place. Dallas District Attorney Henry Wade, who was representing the State of Texas in Roe v Wade, argued that the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment guaranteed preborn human beings equal protection of the law against murder. But the inconsistency of Texas’ anti-abortion laws at the time which didn’t legally penalize mothers for getting abortions provided Justice Harry Blackmun an avenue by which to claim that even pro-life people didn’t really believe abortion was murder. He details this inconsistency in footnote 54 of the Roe v Wade decision.

“There are other inconsistencies between Fourteenth Amendment status and the typical abortion statute. It has already been pointed out, n. 49, supra, that in Texas the woman is not a principal or an accomplice with respect to an abortion upon her. If the fetus is a person, why is the woman not a principal or an accomplice? Further, the penalty for criminal abortion specified by Art. 1195 is significantly less than the maximum penalty for murder prescribed by Art. 1257 of the Texas Penal Code. If the fetus is a person, may the penalties be different?”

Pre-Roe laws failed to treat abortion like murder and thus dehumanized preborn human beings. Blackmun and the 1972 Supreme Court didn’t even have to do the dehumanizing themselves – only point out that pro-life laws already dehumanize the preborn by not giving them equal protection and equal justice.

Whether they be economic, familial, or whatever else, we can all appreciate that there are difficult circumstances that factor into mothers and fathers deciding to kill their sons and daughters. But this cannot mean they get automatic immunity from legal penalty in all cases.

An armed robber might go hungry without the $150 in the till at the corner store. A man might be driven to acts of violence by the physical abuse he suffered as a child. A drunk driver who kills someone might have been drinking because her husband just left her. Such circumstances may warrant a more lenient sentence in some cases, but they do not remove the need for justice to be served. They do not mean that all perpetrators of these crimes should be immune from prosecution because some of them were pressured into the act by a hard situation. Under an abolition bill, like all criminal laws, the exact charges and sentences for mothers and fathers who pay an abortionist to murder their child will be up to prosecutors, judges, and juries and dependent on the specifics of each case. But to afford those who pay to have their child murdered unconditional immunity in all cases is to not actually end abortion as well as to thwart justice.

The Texas legislature meets only every two years, meaning the killing of the Abolition of Abortion in Texas Act is a literal and undeniable death sentence for 110,000 preborn human beings. They will die and be cast into landfills, incineration chambers, and down garbage disposals so that Jeff Leach and his allies among pro-life lobbyists and state Republican leaders can virtue signal that they’re not like those mean abolitionists who actually think preborn human beings should get equal justice and protection.

As a pro-life leader who fights against the abolition of abortion, Leach is not alone. Brian Fisher of Human Coalition, Joe Pojman of Texas Alliance for Life, and Abby Johnson of And Then There Were None have long lobbied against the Abolition of Abortion in Texas Act. Texas is the fourth state where pro-life politicians and lobbyists have killed an abolition bill.


Three Pro-Life Men Are Keeping Abortion Legal in Oklahoma

The Inexhaustible Cowardice of Oklahoma Senate President Greg Treat

Uncovered Letter Exposes Plan to Keep Abortion Legal in Oklahoma


Indiana Pro-Life Leaders Kill Protection at Conception Act


Idaho Pro-Life State Senator Says Ending Abortion “Destroys the Pro-Life Movement”

There are organization who supported TX HB896, however, including
Abolish Abortion Texas, Operation Save America, Concerned Women for America, West Texans For Life, Right to Life of East Texas and a number of Texas pregnancy resource centers. West Texans for Life and Right to Life of East Texas are in no way affiliated with National Right to Life which opposed TX HB896.

To Learn more about abolitionism and the distinctions between it and the pro-life movement, see the two links below:

Immediate, Not Gradual Abolition of Abortion | The Resurgent

The Five Tenets of Abolitionism | Abolish Human Abortion

Correction: This article previously included Texas Right to Life and Kim Schwartz among those lobbying against TX HB896. Schwartz and TRTL were neutral on the bill.


  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • send Email
  • print Print


More Top Stories

Evangelical Politics is Hindering Evangelism

I am an evangelical.  As an evangelical, I believe that the Bible is “God’s revelation of Himself for man,” authored by God, and therefore “without any mixture of error,” as v …

We Must Have Better Solutions Than Lockdowns

I am old enough to remember the catch phrase, “15 days to flatten the curve.” At the onset of the original coronavirus outbreak in America, political leaders and health experts were telling the Am …

Basement Joe Biden Needs to Pick a Silent White Man as VP to His Potted Plant Presidency

Does America want President Karen Bass? Or President Kamala Harris, or President Susan Rice? Because every time an American sees Biden’s smiling mug on television, this thought is going to run along w …